Call us today 1-800-731-2228
Mitch Logo 1-800-731-2228
Get a quote
Make a payment
Mitch Logo
  • Make a payment
  • Self-serve
  • Claims centre
  • About
  • Our team
  • Our insurers
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Media
  • Contact
We have a 4.8-star Google rating!
  • Auto insurance
    • Classic
    • Electric
    • High-risk
    • Pay-as-you-go
    • Right-hand
    • RV
    • Uber and Lyft
  • Home insurance
    • Homeowner
    • Airbnb
    • Condo
    • Cottage
    • High-risk
    • Landlord
    • Tenant
  • Motorcycle insurance
    • Classic
  • Business insurance
    • Contractor
    • Cyber
    • Other
  • Life insurance
    • Term
    • Permanent
    • Group
    • Health
  • Other insurance
    • Boat
    • Pet
    • Snowmobile
    • Everything else
  • Online service
    • Get a quote
    • Make a payment
The latest from mitch blog
  • Car keys. Can you keep your car after it’s been written off by your insurance ...

    April 21, 2025 | 4 min read

  • Car on the road in Ontario during the Spring. Best car insurance companies in Ontario for 2025 

    March 18, 2025 | 8 min read

  • Cars on a highway. How much can I save on car insurance by increasing my deductible?

    February 26, 2025 | 3 min read

  • House. Best home insurance companies in Ontario for 2025

    February 5, 2025 | 7 min read

Visit blog

Nicole Schrader, personal lines service broker.
  1. Home
  2.  > 
  3. About Us
  4.  > 
  5. Team Members
  6.  > 
  7. Nicole Schrader

Nicole Schrader

Sales Broker

Call Email Book
Request Quote

Request an Insurance Quote From Nicole

1-800-731-2228 x5169

Hey there, I’m Nicole!

I’ve been working in insurance since 2012 and came to Mitch in 2018. As a sales broker in personal lines, I love to help people just like you get the insurance they need for their home, cars, and of course all the fun things like motorcycles, cottages, boats, ATVs and snowmobiles!

When you call me for insurance, I make it all about you and your needs. You deserve a broker who is friendly, empathetic, honest, and professional, and that’s me!

I’m literally available at all times, giving you lots of options to contact me when and how it’s convenient for you (phone, text, email). Oh yeah, and if I say I’m going to do something, I do it.

When I’m not helping you with your insurance, you can usually find me on a softball field. I’ve been playing since I was six years old, and to this day, I love getting out with my friends and competing. Our team is based in Ajax. We’re called The Grifters. Do we have fun? Yeah! But we play to win, and we are back-to-back defending champs, baby!

I’m not known as a heavy hitter, but if you call me looking for insurance for that new condo or bike, you can bet I’ll hit a home run for you! Call me for a quote today.

  • becca marshall10/06/2024
    Nicole was very helpful and gave me a great deal on my car insurance.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Al cbr9548/06/2024
    Nicole provides excellent service...would definitely recommend to friends and family.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Katie Barnes7/06/2024
    Nicole wad a gem to work with! She was professional, knowledgeable, and quick to answer emails. She made our insurance renewal seamless! Thanks for the excellent service!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • P Hiwatt6/06/2024
    Nicole was responsive and sorted out a difficult file in record time (Friday afternoon before the long weekend.)
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Rick houle2/29/2024
    Took less than a day to get motorcycle insurance from Nicole, sh was kind and friendly and helpful. Thanks Nicole 😁
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Tariq Kundan2/06/2024
    I switched over to this insurance company for a much better deal. The 2 representatives I dealt with (Nicole S and Stephen V. H) were excellent.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Omar Gaweesh5/24/2023
    Nicole helped me get a great price! Thank you for your hard work!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Ann Trenholme4/24/2023
    I worked with Nicole for an insurance quote. She was amazing. Thank you for all your help.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Muhammad Tariq2/24/2023
    I just new with mitch Insurance so for realy amazing & helpfull .....》 specially Nicole Schrader
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Ron NS2/24/2023
    Nicole's great, informative and interesting!!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Yash Gadhiya2/24/2023
    Nicole and Kara are rockstars! Helped me pick right insurance policy for my car at an afforadable rate!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Muhammad Tariq1/24/2023
    Nicole (mitch Insurance) is helping like problem solving machine she is realy intelligent , hard working ,helpfull,. She find something exactly according to your needs and budget👍
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Sharat Chandra Thuluva12/24/2022
    Excellent customer service by Nicole
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Nichole Prince11/24/2022
    Nicole was great, friendly and knowledgeable. She answered all my questions. Dealt with my quirks. Glad I found her.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Alicia Jabbar11/24/2022
    Nicole thanks so much for your excellent service I will definitely refer my friends and family to join Mitch insurance because of good people like you it is worth this service. May God bless you for ever. Thanks a million Pam Jabbar
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • MICHI Garza10/24/2022
    Was referred by a good friend Louis grant-Calitri, and I’m very glad I took his advice to give you guys a call. I’m new to all this and am pleased how well Nicole helped and explained everything with me. Definitely will recommend.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    W T8/24/2022
    Thank you Nicole for all your help I am Happy with the service I received
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Alex Jurak8/02/2022
    Mitch Insurance helped me out in a pinch when I purchased my first car. Their service was super quick, very flexible, and very informative about the whole process especially for a first time-buyer. Nicole was my advisor and she did a phenomenal job getting me the insurance and information I needed! Definitely recommend!!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Amanda Koleszar12/03/2021
    Mitchell & Whale has been a delight to work with in finding new insurance for our vehicles. Our circumstance was a bit tricky due to issues with our previous broker, but Nicole Schrader was incredibly helpful and did not shy away from the challenge at all. We are so appreciative of the work that has been done on our behalf!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    morsal yazdani10/14/2021
    Nicole was very friendly and helpful with helping me find affordable insurance that worked well for me being a student. Absolutely please with her service! Thank you so much:)
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Waleed Trabulsi9/21/2021
    Thank you Nicole for all your help I am Happy with the service I received
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Nana-Fatima Ukolo8/21/2021
    Thank you Nicole for going above and beyond to get me the best quote!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Nathan Sartore7/21/2021
    We had the pleasure of working with Nicole who made our first time purchasing car insurance very easy! She got us an incredible deal and was very thorough with finding us the right insurance for our needs. Nicole was always easy to get in touch with. We absolutely recommend Nicole and the Mitchell & Whale team for your insurance needs!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Dave Roy6/21/2021
    Friendly staff, I worked with Nicole and she got things done quickly. Great overall experience
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Angela Blakney4/24/2021
    I have always had good quality, professional service from Nicole S.. I have recommended this broker to several of my friends with excellent results. I will continue to recommend ongoing.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Rob Riches3/08/2021
    Nicole was awesome!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Karen Norgan3/08/2021
    Absolutely fabulous service!Nicole could not have been any more helpful!Swift and efficient and knowledgeable!Thanks so much !!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Wendy Brown11/08/2020
    NicoleS Sales Broker & KirstenB AA were very helpful, supportive & professional. I am paying significantly less than I was; excellent experience. I greatly appreciated their support and patience. Thank you
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Kayla Trenholme9/29/2020
    I've been using Mitchell & Whale Insurace for my broker's, and I'm going on my 2nd year with them! I've had the pleasure of dealing with both Sandi and Nicole and they did everything to make it so easy to deal with my insurance needs! When I was quoted something WAY out of my price range, Sandi worked to find me something affordable. They are very prompt in responding and highly professional. They treat you as if you've known them forever instead of a just another client on their books. I would highly recommend contacting Mitchell & Whale for all your insurance needs! If everyone else is just like Sandi and Nicole at Mitchell & Whale you will NOT be disappointed! They represent the company with such care and integrity! Thank you ladies!!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    John H.9/11/2020
    Nicole went the extra mile. She found the right insurance provider, at the right price. ?
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • John Hunter9/05/2020
    Nicole went the extra mile. She found the right insurance provider, at the right price. ?
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Richard Bender9/05/2020
    Our broker agent Nicole did a great job of finding us a company that met our needs for auto and home insurance at a great price.
    She was personable and very knowledgeable when answering our questions concerning changes and additions to our policies.
    Andrea in admin, was very quick in organizing and communicating with us and making sure we understood all aspects of our new policies.
    Dealing with M&W was a breath of fresh air compared to dealing with companies directly.
    Thanks for all your help.
    .
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Adam Corsi7/18/2020
    Nicole is an amazing person!

    I sent Nicole an email asking if she can help me make some changes to a new policy I stated. Not only did she come through for me, she did it within a few hours of receiving my email on a day she was off work! That speaks volumes to the personal touch Nicole offers.

    It’s nice knowing I have a broker I can proudly recommend to my Family and friends. For me, it’s the little things that make a big difference.

    I’m very grateful to Nicole and her colleagues at M&W Insurance for treating me like a friend of the M&W family rather than just another client.

    Cheers!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Jaiden McBride7/10/2020
    Dealt with Nicole Schrader she was incredibly friendly, transparent, quick and clear. She helped me with a quote that I loved and more importantly provided a level of service that helped get insured just in time for delivery day. I would not hesitate to recommend my friends and coworkers to her for a great experience. Thank you Nicole!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    safwaan m.6/15/2020
    Nicole is an amazing person and will get you what you need, she was the cheapest insurance for my bike out of the 20 places I called.Would highly recommend her.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Soultrain S.6/15/2020
    I was calling around making inquiries about house insurance and Nicole Schrader was very prompt to return my call and quickly moved forward to setting it all up. Very impressed with how smooth and quick it was.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • Michael H.6/15/2020
    Fantastic service! Thanks Nicole!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    Anosan Kugathas5/20/2020
    Nicole Schrader was so easy to work with and quick. She got me the best rates possible and no one else could match it. I would highly recommend using her as she is fantastic to work with, while also providing you with the best service and prices. Thanks for your help.
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    600 M.3/05/2020
    Had the pleasure of working with Nicole Schrader on a motorcycle insurance policy. She was very professional, answered all of my questions and got me an incredible rate.Thanks for your help Nicole!
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
  • s s.2/15/2020
    My lucky broker of nicole Schrader was the best broker ever she found me a great insurance rate gave me great advice and so friendly almost forgot I was shopping for car insurance. She deserves a raise. -byron montoya-
    read moreread less
    Google Logo
    s s.2/13/2020
    My lucky broker of nicole Schrader was the best broker ever she found me a great insurance rate gave me great advice and so friendly almost forgot I was shopping for car insurance. She deserves a raise. -byron montoya-
    read moreread less
    Google Logo

Didn’t find what you were looking for?

Check out some of our other insurance products.

Get insurance quotes

Who’s Mitch?

Mitch is a leading insurance brokerage on a mission to make insurance lovable through exceptional experiences. Family-owned since 1948, the brokerage works with more than 70 of Canada’s top insurance companies. An unwavering supporter for consumer and public good, Mitch believes that everyone deserves fair and transparent insurance.

Mitch Insurance Brokers is operated by Mitchell & Whale Insurance Brokers Ltd.

Meet our leadership team.

Insurance products

  • Auto insurance
  • Home insurance
  • Business insurance
  • Motorcycle insurance
  • Snowmobile insurance
  • Cyber insurance
  • Life insurance

Latest from our blog

  • Car keys.

    Can you keep your car after it’s been written off by your insurance company?

    April 21, 2025 4 min read
  • Car on the road in Ontario during the Spring.

    Best car insurance companies in Ontario for 2025 

    March 18, 2025 8 min read
  • Cars on a highway.

    How much can I save on car insurance by increasing my deductible?

    February 26, 2025 3 min read

Contact Info

Head Office
Mitch Insurance Brokers

1555 Wentworth St. Unit 200, Whitby
Ontario L1N 9T6

1-800-731-2228
(905) 579-9701
info@mitchinsurance.com
 

Toronto
Mitch Insurance Brokers

296 Richmond St W Suite 212, Toronto, ON M5V 1X2

1-888-401-4697
(289) 593-0275
info@mitchinsurance.com

  • Corporate policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms and conditions
  • Accessibility
  • RIBO conduct
  • Customer conduct
  • Sitemap
Copyright © 2012 - 2025